Mud-club

Vehicle & Technical => Discovery => Topic started by: Skippy on August 25, 2005, 18:55:32

Title: MOT Fail On Oil Leak?
Post by: Skippy on August 25, 2005, 18:55:32
Has anybody else had their Landrover fail on a power steering box oil leak, or any other leak for that matter?  :shock:  

For gods sake, it's a landrover it's going to leak!?
Title: MOT Fail On Oil Leak?
Post by: muddyweb on August 25, 2005, 18:57:35
Not recently, but yes.

Any oil leak is potentially a test failure... a lot depends on the tester's discretion.
Title: MOT Fail On Oil Leak?
Post by: Dr Neil on August 25, 2005, 18:59:10
i would of thought it depended on how bad the leak was, whether it was getting onto the brakes or if it was affecting the way the power steering operated.
Title: MOT Fail On Oil Leak?
Post by: hobbit on August 25, 2005, 20:21:48
Unfortunately its a common fault on these boxes, and yes they will fail.

But you can try some additive to reduce the leak, or wipe down the box before you take it in for the mot, it may be a slow leak,

Some of the probs are from two pipes that go into the top of the steering box, they have a rubber grommet inside to seal it.

If its the bottom seal, bit more of a swine there, some can strip and be replaced, but like mine it was a unit change, not a great problem, and there are 2nd hand units available

Clean and dry the unit, swing it from lock to lock and have a look above and below for the leak, then take it from there
Title: MOT Fail On Oil Leak?
Post by: seph234 on August 25, 2005, 20:24:30
i got told to jet wash mine off of the box before the test then it only looked like it was a small leak and he gave me an advisory to get it done
Title: MOT Fail On Oil Leak?
Post by: Alan Robertson on August 25, 2005, 20:49:39
Mine has had a small leak for years. A good de-grease with Gunk or similar just before the MOT has always done the trick.
Title: MOT Fail On Oil Leak?
Post by: The Fat Controller on August 25, 2005, 21:42:32
m.o.t testers are a rule to themselves,the main rules are
1.will they get leaked on?
2.will they get dirty?
if you can reduce the chance of either of these they can be nearly human
 :lol:  :lol:  :lol:  :lol:  :lol:
Title: MOT Fail On Oil Leak?
Post by: beast5680 on August 25, 2005, 22:06:41
mine has a leak from the input shaft and if you leave it for a while it looks really bad as the oil spreads along the chassis but i cleaned it all off with degreaser and brake cleaner the day before the mot and it went straight thru
Title: MOT Fail On Oil Leak?
Post by: Sharpshooter on August 26, 2005, 09:57:11
My tester said to me. "Have you just topped up you power steering fluid mate, To which i was going to say No, until i saw him winking, and he said "well you must have spilt a bit on the pump"

"Oh yes i replied :lol:
Title: MOT Fail On Oil Leak?
Post by: Range Rover Blues on August 26, 2005, 12:00:15
When a steering box leaks from the main seal it can be indicative of wear in the main bearing, so it's on it's way out.  That said it takes a long time for it to become any worse.

The rule about leaks is not an easy one to apply, then it also depends on the tester's interpretation too.  A swivel can have a slow leak and provided it isn't running onto the road or any other componenets like rubber bushes or the brakes it can be left.  The steering however is a bit more serious, no one is going to looses control of their car because the swivel lost all it's oil (unless it seized) whereas if the PAS fluid ran out it could be bad!
Title: MOT Fail On Oil Leak?
Post by: TimM on August 26, 2005, 13:54:10
I have a feeling that a leak that you would fail for is one that is likely to lead to your vehicle dripping sufficent fluid on the road to cause a danger to other road users, presumably for puddles of oil at a junction which could cause motorbikes etc to skid or fall off.

If this is right then any 'slow' leaks should be OK, if anyone wants to know for sure let me know as I know a tester and he can give me the 'official' rubbish from his book.

Tim.
Title: MOT Fail On Oil Leak?
Post by: cstokes on August 27, 2005, 20:55:29
The official line on mot is that, transmission or engine oil leaks are not part of the mot unless it is affecting the operation of anouther system or component such as the braking system. ie: a crankshaft seal leak is not a fail but if it was being flung onto a front brake caliper or disc then it would be a fail.  All power steering leaks or brake fluid leaks are automatically a fail.
Title: MOT Fail On Oil Leak?
Post by: Dr Neil on August 27, 2005, 21:46:41
:-k
Title: MOT Fail On Oil Leak?
Post by: muddyweb on August 27, 2005, 21:51:25
As I understand it, they can also refuse to test a vehicle due to oil leaks in the same way they can if it is too dirty.
Title: MOT Fail On Oil Leak?
Post by: Skippy on August 30, 2005, 22:06:42
Cheers for that guys, it's always interesting to hear the jargon that the testers hide behind!! :twisted:

It's all sorted now, although when you add all the welding that needed doing it came to over 500 quid  :shock:

SKINT AGAIN!
Title: MOT Fail On Oil Leak?
Post by: seph234 on August 30, 2005, 22:32:36
these land rovers are good arnt they :lol:  :lol:
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal